Skor broker berbobot biaya dan cara menghitungnya

Trust Score tetap merupakan ukuran terpisah 0–100 untuk perlindungan struktural. Peringkat berbobot nilai menambahkan bukti biaya terverifikasi agar jumlah lisensi tidak menentukan urutan sendirian.

Dipelihara oleh Priya Nair, Kepala Regulasi & Keamanan · Dihitung ulang setiap 90 hari

Formula

Perhitungan, secara lengkap

Tidak ada ketentuan tersembunyi, tidak ada penyesuaian diskresioner.

value score = 0.70 × trust + 0.30 × fee evidence trust = 0.55 × safety + 0.25 × reach + 0.20 × longevity safety = Trust & Safety pillar score (0–10) × 10 reach = min(100, tier1 × 22 + tier2 × 9 + tier3 × 3) longevity = min(100, (2026 − year founded) × 3.4) fee evidence = audited Fees & Costs pillar × 10; otherwise 100 − (observed spread × 50); no verified fee evidence = 0 result is rounded to the nearest whole number

Mengapa keamanan memiliki bobot 55%

Pilar Kepercayaan & Keamanan adalah satu-satunya komponen yang mencerminkan apa yang kami amati secara langsung: pengaturan segregasi, perlindungan saldo negatif yang benar-benar diterapkan pada akun kami, kelayakan skema kompensasi untuk entitas tempat kami di-onboarding, dan apakah meja pembayaran bertindak sesuai saat kami meminta semuanya kembali. Ini membawa sebagian besar bobot karena ini adalah satu-satunya bagian dari skor yang dibangun di atas bukti daripada catatan publik.

Mengapa jangkauan dibatasi

Lisensi tier-1 bernilai kira-kira dua setengah lisensi tier-2 dan tujuh lisensi tier-3 dalam model ini, dan totalnya dibatasi pada 100 sehingga broker tidak dapat mengumpulkan skor tak terbatas dengan mendaftar di banyak yurisdiksi kecil. Mengumpulkan 'offshore wrapper' tidak sama dengan diawasi.

Mengapa masa beroperasi hanya 20%

Bertahan selama tiga puluh tahun di industri ini sangat berarti — ini berarti sebuah perusahaan telah melewati beberapa rezim regulasi dan setidaknya dua krisis likuiditas tanpa runtuh. Namun usia saja tidak melindungi siapa pun, sehingga dibatasi sekitar tiga puluh tahun operasi dan tidak pernah diizinkan mendominasi hasil keamanan yang lemah.

Apa yang sengaja dikecualikan

Spread, komisi, kualitas platform, riset, promosi, bonus, penghargaan di tempat lain, pengeluaran pemasaran, dan hubungan komersial dengan kami. Biaya terverifikasi dapat memengaruhi skor nilai sesuai aturan yang dipublikasikan; tidak meningkatkan Trust Score terpisah, dan membayar kami tidak meningkatkan skor apa pun.

Beroperasi

Setiap broker, komponen per komponen

Tiga angka yang sama menghasilkan setiap angka utama.

#	Broker	Skor berbobot nilai	Kepercayaan	Bukti biaya ×0.30	Keamanan ×0.55	Jangkauan ×0.25	Durasi ×0.20	Kategori	T1	T2	T3
1	OANDA	94	98	83 → 24.9	97 → 53.4	100 → 25.0	100 → 20.0	98	Luar Biasa	5	0	0
2	Interactive Brokers	93	94	92 → 27.6	95 → 52.3	88 → 22.0	100 → 20.0	94	Luar Biasa	4	0	0
3	Saxo Bank	91	95	80 → 24.0	90 → 49.5	100 → 25.0	100 → 20.0	95	Luar Biasa	5	0	0
4	FOREX.com	91	93	87 → 26.1	97 → 53.4	91 → 22.8	85 → 17.0	93	Luar Biasa	4	0	1
5	IG Group	91	93	85 → 25.5	87 → 47.9	100 → 25.0	100 → 20.0	93	Luar Biasa	7	0	0
6	Pepperstone	88	87	91 → 27.3	95 → 52.3	96 → 24.0	54 → 10.8	87	Kuat	3	3	1
7	CMC Markets	86	89	80 → 24.0	95 → 52.3	66 → 16.5	100 → 20.0	89	Kuat	3	0	0
8	Plus500	82	82	82 → 24.6	95 → 52.3	71 → 17.8	61 → 12.2	82	Kuat	2	3	0
9	AvaTrade	81	82	78 → 23.4	92 → 50.6	71 → 17.8	68 → 13.6	82	Kuat	2	3	0
10	FxPro	81	78	89 → 26.7	97 → 53.4	43 → 10.8	68 → 13.6	78	Kuat	1	2	1
11	ATFX	78	78	78 → 23.4	90 → 49.5	90 → 22.5	31 → 6.2	78	Memadai	3	2	2
12	Capital.com	78	75	85 → 25.5	90 → 49.5	74 → 18.5	34 → 6.8	75	Memadai	2	3	1
13	Axi	76	72	85 → 25.5	78 → 42.9	65 → 16.3	65 → 13.0	72	Memadai	2	2	1
14	eToro	73	76	65 → 19.5	90 → 49.5	53 → 13.3	65 → 13.0	76	Memadai	2	1	0
15	Eightcap	73	68	85 → 25.5	75 → 41.3	62 → 15.5	58 → 11.6	68	Memadai	2	1	3
16	City Index	72	70	75 → 22.5	70 → 38.5	44 → 11.0	100 → 20.0	70	Memadai	2	0	0
17	Exness	71	64	88 → 26.4	75 → 41.3	43 → 10.8	61 → 12.2	64	Memadai	1	2	1
18	Tickmill	71	60	95 → 28.5	70 → 38.5	52 → 13.0	41 → 8.2	60	Memadai	1	3	1
19	IC Markets	70	63	87 → 26.1	75 → 41.3	34 → 8.5	65 → 13.0	63	Memadai	1	1	1
20	FXCM	69	71	65 → 19.5	70 → 38.5	56 → 14.0	92 → 18.4	71	Tonton	2	1	1
21	HFM (formerly HotForex)	69	65	78 → 23.4	70 → 38.5	64 → 16.0	54 → 10.8	65	Tonton	1	4	2
22	XM	68	65	75 → 22.5	78 → 42.9	43 → 10.8	58 → 11.6	65	Tonton	1	2	1
23	XTB	68	65	75 → 22.5	70 → 38.5	40 → 10.0	82 → 16.4	65	Tonton	1	2	0
24	ActivTrades	67	64	75 → 22.5	70 → 38.5	34 → 8.5	85 → 17.0	64	Tonton	1	1	1
25	Admirals (Admiral Markets)	67	63	75 → 22.5	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	85 → 17.0	63	Tonton	1	1	0
26	IUX (IUX Markets)	66	56	90 → 27.0	73 → 40.2	37 → 9.3	34 → 6.8	56	Tonton	1	1	2
27	Spreadex	64	62	70 → 21.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	92 → 18.4	62	Tonton	1	0	0
28	JustMarkets	64	55	85 → 25.5	70 → 38.5	27 → 6.8	48 → 9.6	55	Tonton	0	2	3
29	Decode Global	59	61	55 → 16.5	70 → 38.5	28 → 7.0	75 → 15.0	61	Low combined evidence	1	0	2
30	Octa (formerly OctaFX)	59	54	70 → 21.0	70 → 38.5	21 → 5.3	51 → 10.2	54	Low combined evidence	0	2	1
31	XS.com	58	64	45 → 13.5	70 → 38.5	58 → 14.5	54 → 10.8	64	Low combined evidence	1	3	3
32	FBS	57	53	65 → 19.5	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	58 → 11.6	53	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
33	Swissquote	54	70	15 → 4.5	70 → 38.5	44 → 11.0	100 → 20.0	70	Low combined evidence	2	0	0
34	Equiti	54	64	30 → 9.0	70 → 38.5	52 → 13.0	61 → 12.2	64	Low combined evidence	1	3	1
35	TMGM	54	55	50 → 15.0	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	44 → 8.8	55	Low combined evidence	1	0	3
36	Trading 212	53	75	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	84 → 21.0	75 → 15.0	75	Low combined evidence	3	2	0
37	BlackBull Markets	53	50	60 → 18.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	41 → 8.2	50	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
38	Land Prime	51	49	55 → 16.5	70 → 38.5	6 → 1.5	44 → 8.8	49	Low combined evidence	0	0	2
39	TradeStation Global	50	59	30 → 9.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	75 → 15.0	59	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
40	PU Prime	49	55	35 → 10.5	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	37 → 7.4	55	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
41	tastyfx	49	44	60 → 18.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	0 → 0.0	44	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
42	Windsor Brokers	47	67	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	33 → 8.3	100 → 20.0	67	Low combined evidence	0	3	2
43	FP Markets	46	66	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	52 → 13.0	71 → 14.2	66	Low combined evidence	1	3	1
44	Vantage (Vantage Markets)	46	66	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	62 → 15.5	58 → 11.6	66	Low combined evidence	2	1	3
45	easyMarkets	46	65	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	85 → 17.0	65	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
46	Deriv	45	64	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	27 → 6.8	92 → 18.4	64	Low combined evidence	0	1	6
47	D Prime (formerly Doo Prime)	45	64	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	69 → 17.3	41 → 8.2	64	Low combined evidence	3	0	1
48	Trade Nation	45	64	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	68 → 17.0	41 → 8.2	64	Low combined evidence	2	2	2
49	ThinkMarkets	44	63	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	56 → 14.0	54 → 10.8	63	Low combined evidence	2	1	1
50	GO Markets	43	62	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	40 → 10.0	68 → 13.6	62	Low combined evidence	1	1	3
51	Century Financial	43	61	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	100 → 20.0	61	Low combined evidence	0	1	0
52	Dukascopy	43	61	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	75 → 15.0	61	Low combined evidence	1	1	0
53	FXOpen	43	61	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	34 → 8.5	71 → 14.2	61	Low combined evidence	1	1	1
54	Fortrade	42	60	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	87 → 21.8	0 → 0.0	60	Low combined evidence	3	2	1
55	NinjaTrader	42	60	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	78 → 15.6	60	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
56	FXTM (ForexTime)	41	59	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	43 → 10.8	51 → 10.2	59	Low combined evidence	1	2	1
57	Alpari	41	58	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	95 → 19.0	58	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
58	LMAX Global	40	57	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	54 → 10.8	57	Low combined evidence	1	1	0
59	One Financial Markets	40	57	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	65 → 13.0	57	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
60	Global Prime	39	56	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	25 → 6.3	54 → 10.8	56	Low combined evidence	1	0	1
61	LiteFinance	39	56	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	15 → 3.8	71 → 14.2	56	Low combined evidence	0	1	2
62	Scope Markets	39	56	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	36 → 9.0	41 → 8.2	56	Low combined evidence	0	3	3
63	Taurex	39	55	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	40 → 10.0	31 → 6.2	55	Low combined evidence	1	1	3
64	Ultima Markets	39	55	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	34 → 6.8	55	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
65	AMarkets	38	54	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	65 → 13.0	54	Low combined evidence	0	0	3
66	InstaForex	38	54	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	65 → 13.0	54	Low combined evidence	0	1	0
67	STARTRADER	38	54	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	43 → 10.8	24 → 4.8	54	Low combined evidence	1	1	4
68	Valutrades	38	54	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	25 → 6.3	48 → 9.6	54	Low combined evidence	1	0	1
69	Markets4you (formerly Forex4you)	37	53	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	6 → 1.5	65 → 13.0	53	Low combined evidence	0	0	2
70	Grand Capital	37	53	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	68 → 13.6	53	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
71	RoboForex	37	53	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	58 → 11.6	53	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
72	Fusion Markets	36	52	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	28 → 7.0	31 → 6.2	52	Low combined evidence	1	0	2
73	Hantec Markets	36	52	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	53 → 13.3	0 → 0.0	52	Low combined evidence	2	0	3
74	Orbex	36	52	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	51 → 10.2	52	Low combined evidence	0	0	4
75	ADSS	36	51	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	51 → 10.2	51	Low combined evidence	0	1	0
76	TIOmarkets	36	51	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	24 → 4.8	51	Low combined evidence	1	0	3
77	Traders Trust	36	51	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	58 → 11.6	51	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
78	IQ Option	35	50	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	44 → 8.8	50	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
79	Key To Markets	35	50	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	54 → 10.8	50	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
80	Moneta Markets	35	50	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	46 → 11.5	0 → 0.0	50	Low combined evidence	1	2	2
81	Purple Trading	35	50	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	18 → 4.5	37 → 7.4	50	Low combined evidence	0	2	0
82	CPT Markets	34	48	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	0 → 0.0	48	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
83	IronFX	34	48	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	0 → 0.0	48	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
84	Skilling	34	48	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	34 → 6.8	48	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
85	VT Markets	34	48	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	37 → 9.3	0 → 0.0	48	Low combined evidence	1	1	2
86	Milton Markets	33	47	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	6 → 1.5	34 → 6.8	47	Low combined evidence	0	0	2
87	Zero Markets	33	47	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	34 → 8.5	0 → 0.0	47	Low combined evidence	1	1	1
88	Exclusive Markets	33	39	20 → 6.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	0 → 0.0	39	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
89	Blueberry (formerly Blueberry Markets)	32	46	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	28 → 7.0	0 → 0.0	46	Low combined evidence	1	0	2
90	Errante	32	46	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	24 → 4.8	46	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
91	HYCM	32	46	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	31 → 7.8	0 → 0.0	46	Low combined evidence	1	1	0
92	Trive Financial	31	45	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	24 → 6.0	0 → 0.0	45	Low combined evidence	0	2	2
93	Charles Schwab Futures and Forex	31	44	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	0 → 0.0	44	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
94	M4Markets	31	44	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	21 → 5.3	0 → 0.0	44	Low combined evidence	0	2	1
95	Markets.com	31	44	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	21 → 5.3	0 → 0.0	44	Low combined evidence	0	2	1
96	Rakuten Securities Australia	31	44	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	22 → 5.5	0 → 0.0	44	Low combined evidence	1	0	0
97	Sway Markets	30	43	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	17 → 3.4	43	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
98	ThreeTrader	30	43	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	6 → 1.5	17 → 3.4	43	Low combined evidence	0	0	2
99	Fondex	29	42	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	0 → 0.0	42	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
100	FXGT.com	29	42	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	15 → 3.8	0 → 0.0	42	Low combined evidence	0	1	2
101	FXPrimus	29	42	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	0 → 0.0	42	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
102	NAGA	29	42	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	0 → 0.0	42	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
103	Weltrade	29	42	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	12 → 3.0	0 → 0.0	42	Low combined evidence	0	1	1
104	Libertex	29	41	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	0 → 0.0	41	Low combined evidence	0	1	0
105	NordFX	29	41	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	0 → 0.0	41	Low combined evidence	0	0	3
106	TitanFX	29	41	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	9 → 2.3	0 → 0.0	41	Low combined evidence	0	0	3
107	Axiory	28	40	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	6 → 1.5	0 → 0.0	40	Low combined evidence	0	0	2
108	FreshForex	27	39	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	0 → 0.0	39	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
109	Gulf Brokers	27	39	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	0 → 0.0	39	Low combined evidence	0	0	1
110	Squared Financial	27	39	0 → 0.0	70 → 38.5	3 → 0.8	0 → 0.0	39	Low combined evidence	0	0	1

Komponen ditampilkan mentah terlebih dahulu, kemudian dikalikan dengan bobotnya. Perbedaan pembulatan kecil antara jumlah ketiga kolom berbobot dan angka utama berasal dari pembulatan hasil akhir sekali, di akhir.

Skala

Cara membaca band

Rentang	Kategori	Apa artinya dalam praktik
90–100	Luar Biasa	Strong combined evidence across structural protection and verified trading costs; inspect the separate Trust Score before depositing.
80–89	Kuat	Good combined value evidence, with the Trust Score and fee evidence shown as separate components.
70–79	Memadai	A middle combined score. Read the licence entity, cost basis and unresolved fields rather than treating the band as a recommendation.
60–69	Tonton	The combined score is sensitive to either weaker structural protection or incomplete cost evidence. Check both components.
below 60	Low combined evidence	The value-aware score is below 60; this is not a standalone safety verdict and missing fee evidence can lower it.

Konteks

Korelasi Skor Kepercayaan dengan skor keseluruhan

Dua pertanyaan berbeda, dua bobot berbeda.

Pilar	Bobot dalam skor keseluruhan	Memasukkan Skor Kepercayaan?	Variabel
Fees & Costs	30%	No	26
Trust & Safety	20%	Yes — 55%	21
Deposits & Withdrawals	15%	No	18
Trading Platforms	15%	No	24
Product Range	10%	No	15
Research & Education	5%	No	14
Customer Support	3%	No	12
Account Opening	2%	No	10
Total	100%	ditambah jangkauan dan umur panjang, dari daftar publik	140

Broker dapat memiliki skor keseluruhan tinggi dan Trust Score moderat jika berdagang dengan biaya rendah dari basis regulasi yang lebih tipis — OANDA dan Squared Financial berada di ujung yang berlawanan dari pertukaran tersebut. Baca kedua angka sebelum melakukan deposit. Setiap bidang data yang dicatat →